Where this deviates from the assignment a little bit, I uncovered a slander case that struck me as very interesting and because these assignments are considerably freelance, I wanted to write about this case in particular because I figured it would help hone my investigative ethical skills better.
A woman, Missy Chase Lapine, wrote a cook book that was titled The Sneaky Chef: Simple Strategies for Hiding Healthy Foods in Kids. Shortly after her cook book was published, Jessica Seinfeld, wife of Jerry Seinfeld, authored a book entitled Deceptively Delicious: Simple Secrets to Get Your Kids Eating Good Food.
Where this case started as a case based on the grounds of plagiarism, it became a case based in terms of slander.
Just by comparing the titles of the two cook books, one may expect that there are going to be similar themes with the diction and recipes in the books. After Lapine read the cook book that Seinfeld had published, she pointed out that there were conclusive signs of infringement and plagiarism. These two charges were the initial allegations in the sentence; however, after Jerry Seinfeld was a guest on the Letterman Show, slander and defamation charges were also made.
It was believed that Jerry Seinfeld used his celebrity status to defame Lapine. On the Letterman show, he called her such names as wacko and nut-job. Seinfeld also claimed that Lapine is hysterical for the previously mentioned allegations of infringement and plagiarism.
In accordance with the statements made in the article that is attached to this blog, I too believe that Jerry Seinfeld was not defaming the character or integrity of Missy Chase Lapine. I do believe that the words said about her were unnecessary, to say the least. However, by no means were they malicious, nor do I think the Jerry Seinfeld used them to manipulate anyone into believing anything bad about Missy Lapine.
I did not find any resolution on the case between the Seinfelds and Missy Chase Lapine. This very well may be because charges were dropped. Regardless, in the hypothetical situation that I was the one determining this case, I would find the Seinfelds not guilty of defamation. I don’t believe that Jerry Seinfeld should be exempt from the freedom of speech just because his level of celebrity status.